The Biblioblog Top 50

Monthly rankings of the top biblical studies blogs

Archive for the ‘Biblioblog News’ Category

The Biblioblog Library is on the Fritz

Posted by Steve Caruso on December 6, 2012

We’re trying to keep the hit counter functional while we figure out a better solution. For more information, visit The Reference Librarian’s Blog.

Peace,
-Steve

Posted in Biblioblog News, Biblioblog Top 50 | Tagged: , | Leave a Comment »

Top 50 Biblioblogs & Carnival for November 2012

Posted by Steve Caruso on November 30, 2012

I’m getting back on the horse with this…

First, a quick announcement:

New, awesome stuff is coming in the Biblioblogging world.

The Biblioblog Reference Library is going through another revision and I am *finally* (yes I know you’ll believe it when you see it) releasing user accounts to the public. Hopefully, too, this will speed things up dramatically.

The Archives currently hold over 10 GIGABYTES of archived blog data, articles, and comments. In short, Biblioblogging is prolific.

More updates are forthcoming.

Now, on with the stats:

This Month’s Biblioblog Top 50

Courtesy of The Biblioblog Reference Library:

All Hail James McGrath as this month’s #1 Biblioblogger!

# Hits Blog Tracker Library
1 135563 Exploring Our Matrix Blog tracking for rankings installed. 134029 1534
2 36427 Near Emmaus Blog tracking for rankings installed. 36130 297
3 27359 Unsettled Christianity Blog tracking for rankings installed. 26190 1169
4 23036 TILL HE COMES Blog tracking for rankings installed. 22741 295
5 20238 TaborBlog Blog tracking for rankings installed. 20115 123
6 18752 Ancient Hebrew Poetry Blog tracking for rankings installed. 18717 35
7 18612 Reading Acts Blog tracking for rankings installed. 18322 290
8 17567 Debunking Christianity Blog tracking *was* installed, but is currently missing. 17161 406
9 17419 XKV8R: The Official Blog of Dr. Robert R. Cargill Blog tracking for rankings installed. 17250 169
10 16939 Remnant of Giants Blog tracking for rankings installed. 16808 131
11 12569 Aantekeningen bij de Bijbel Blog tracking for rankings installed. 12328 241
12 12183 Scotteriology Blog tracking for rankings installed. 11647 536
13 9760 Gentle Wisdom Blog tracking for rankings installed. 9695 65
14 9482 NT Blog Blog tracking for rankings installed. 9302 180
15 8289 The Naked Bible Blog tracking for rankings installed. 8168 121
16 8240 BLT Blog tracking for rankings installed. 7988 252
17 7815 Political Jesus Blog tracking for rankings installed. 7321 494
18 5836 The Musings of Thomas Verenna Blog tracking for rankings installed. 5659 177
19 5288 Alin Suciu Blog tracking for rankings installed. 5186 102
20 4915 A ‘Goula Blogger Blog tracking for rankings installed. 4778 137
21 4695 BibleX Blog tracking for rankings installed. 4493 202
22 4522 Professor Obvious Blog tracking for rankings installed. 4509 13
23 4227 Observatório Bíblico Blog tracking for rankings installed. 4064 163
24 3520 The Aramaic Blog Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3240 280
25 3194 Textuality Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3121 73
26 2919 καὶ τὰ λοιπά Blog tracking for rankings installed. 2865 54
27 2831 Zwinglius Redivivus Blog tracking *was* installed, but is currently missing. 1 2830
28 2299 Ketuvim: the Writings of James R. Getz Jr. Blog tracking for rankings installed. 2274 25
29 2204 Jesus Creed 0 2204
30 2191 Participatory Bible Study Blog Blog tracking for rankings installed. 2119 72
31 1819 NT Pod Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1808 11
32 1730 Grace Commentary Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1674 56
33 1402 Sansblogue Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1316 86
34 1392 Abnormal Interests Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1293 99
35 1296 5 Minute Bible Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1233 63
36 1201 The Biblioblog Top 50 Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1157 44
37 835 Aristotle’s Feminist Subject Blog tracking for rankings installed. 637 198
38 744 Polumeros kai Polutropos Blog tracking for rankings installed. 697 47
39 697 Pisteuomen Blog tracking for rankings installed. 646 51
40 597 Ιστολόγιο βιβλικών σπουδών / Biblical Studies Blog 0 597
41 441 Dust Blog tracking for rankings installed. 346 95
42 415 Euangelion 0 415
43 409 James’ Thoughts and Musings 0 409
44 382 PaleoJudaica.com 0 382
45 376 The Forbidden Gospels 0 376
46 338 Suzanne’s Bookshelf 0 338
47 288 Bible Films Blog 0 288
48 272 Quadrilateral Thoughts 0 272
49 240 BiblicalStudies.org.uk 0 240
50 210 Evangelical Textual Criticism 0 210

This Month’s Biblioblog Carnival

Hosted over at Dust by Bob MacDonald.

Biblical Studies Carnival
All Souls to St Andrew’s Day 2012
no noyse nor silence but one equall musick

Check it out.

Peace,
-Steve

Posted in Biblioblog News, Biblioblog Top 50 | 8 Comments »

BLT Hosting the Next Biblioblog Carnival

Posted by Steve Caruso on October 17, 2012

BLT is hosting the next Biblioblog Carnival!

JK Gayle is accepting the submissions, so get in contact if you’d like to participate.

More Biblioblog-related stuff is also on the way I’m going to be picking the Biblioblog Top 50 back up with a bunch of fun stuff over at The Biblioblog Reference Library. So watch this space. :-) Life has been busy busy busy.

Peace,
-Steve

Posted in Biblioblog News | Tagged: | 5 Comments »

Biblioblog Rankings – November 2011

Posted by Steve Caruso on December 2, 2011

Yep, this month it’s a day late. I’m moving! Things are crazy. :-)

Without further ado:

# Hits Blog Tracker Library
1 135753 Jesus Creed Blog tracking *was* installed, but is currently missing. (Fix your counter! :-) ) 134872 881
2 78494 Debunking Christianity Blog tracking for rankings installed. 78037 457
3 41909 TILL HE COMES Blog tracking for rankings installed. 41688 221
4 39546 Unsettled Christianity Blog tracking for rankings installed. 38613 933
5 25398 Near Emmaus Blog tracking for rankings installed. 24877 521
6 20964 Ancient Hebrew Poetry Blog tracking for rankings installed. 20879 85
7 17600 Scotteriology Blog tracking for rankings installed. 16266 1334
8 15544 Better Bibles Blog Blog tracking for rankings installed. 15454 90
9 11030 Aantekeningen bij de Bijbel Blog tracking for rankings installed. 10725 305
10 10847 Remnant of Giants Blog tracking for rankings installed. 10663 184
11 10409 NT Blog Blog tracking for rankings installed. 10302 107
12 10326 Reading Acts Blog tracking for rankings installed. 10156 170
13 9202 XKV8R: The Official Blog of Dr. Robert R. Cargill Blog tracking for rankings installed. 9087 115
14 7270 Gentle Wisdom Blog tracking for rankings installed. 7098 172
15 6824 Political Jesus Blog tracking for rankings installed. 5566 1258
16 6217 Observatório Bíblico Blog tracking for rankings installed. 6018 199
17 5828 Alin Suciu Blog tracking for rankings installed. 5776 52
18 5490 Participatory Bible Study Blog Blog tracking for rankings installed. 5436 54
19 5477 καὶ τὰ λοιπά Blog tracking for rankings installed. 5406 71
20 5437 Targuman Blog tracking for rankings installed. 5350 87
21 5411 Textuality Blog tracking for rankings installed. 5287 124
22 4399 The Aramaic Blog Blog tracking for rankings installed. 4116 283
23 4387 BibleX Blog tracking for rankings installed. 4123 264
24 4076 Zwinglius Redivivus 0 4076
25 4028 Pisteuomen Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3949 79
26 3978 Dr. Claude Mariottini – Professor of Old Testament Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3847 131
27 3789 BLT Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3662 127
28 3734 A ‘Goula Blogger Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3637 97
29 3708 Professor Obvious Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3678 30
30 3437 Exploring Our Matrix Blog tracking for rankings installed. 2529 908
31 3314 Diglotting Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3193 121
32 3010 The Musings of Thomas Verenna Blog tracking for rankings installed. 2844 166
33 2910 NT Pod Blog tracking for rankings installed. 2878 32
34 2423 Ketuvim: the Writings of James R. Getz Jr. Blog tracking for rankings installed. 2385 38
35 2178 Aristotle’s Feminist Subject Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1468 710
36 2086 Grace Commentary Blog tracking for rankings installed. 2067 19
37 1987 5 Minute Bible Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1762 225
38 1984 The Biblioblog Top 50 Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1905 79
39 1492 Ιστολόγιο βιβλικών σπουδών / Biblical Studies Blog 0 1492
40 1480 Abnormal Interests Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1302 178
41 1453 Polumeros kai Polutropos Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1407 46
42 1403 Sansblogue Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1334 69
43 1107 AD CUMMULUS Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1049 58
44 869 Suzanne’s Bookshelf 0 869
45 863 Bible Films Blog 0 863
46 845 Dust Blog tracking for rankings installed. 718 127
47 789 The Forbidden Gospels 0 789
48 685 BiblicalStudies.org.uk 0 685
49 426 PaleoJudaica.com 0 426
50 381 Daniel O. McClellan 0 381

This Month’s Biblical Studies Carnival

Over on Remnant of Giants, Deane has hosted the Biblical Studies Carnival 69 (November 2011). Check it out!

New Carnival Cycle and Organizer

Jim Linville of Dr. Jim’s Thinking Shop is organizing the 2012 Biblical Studies Carnivals. If you wish to host a Carnival in the upcoming year, be sure to get in contact with him!

More Anouncements After The Move! — Hopefully by Christmas– hopefully…

Peace,
-Steve

Posted in Biblioblog News, Biblioblog Top 50 | 7 Comments »

Biblioblog Rankings – October 2011

Posted by Steve Caruso on November 1, 2011

Sorry it’s a bit late, but here they are:

Jesus Creed has taken a very firm lead with nearly 200,000 article reads!

# Hits Blog Tracker Library
1 196562 Jesus Creed Blog tracking for rankings installed. 195358 1204
2 97829 TILL HE COMES Blog tracking for rankings installed. 97536 293
3 88106 Debunking Christianity Blog tracking for rankings installed. 87551 555
4 50534 Exploring Our Matrix Blog tracking for rankings installed. 49086 1448
5 35482 Unsettled Christianity Blog tracking for rankings installed. 34022 1460
6 23267 Near Emmaus Blog tracking for rankings installed. 22576 691
7 19216 Ancient Hebrew Poetry Blog tracking for rankings installed. 19042 174
8 18776 Scotteriology Blog tracking for rankings installed. 16737 2039
9 14578 Better Bibles Blog Blog tracking for rankings installed. 14410 168
10 10434 Aantekeningen bij de Bijbel Blog tracking for rankings installed. 10009 425
11 10171 NT Blog Blog tracking for rankings installed. 10002 169
12 9179 XKV8R: The Official Blog of Dr. Robert R. Cargill Blog tracking for rankings installed. 8963 216
13 8353 Political Jesus Blog tracking for rankings installed. 6050 2303
14 8213 Reading Acts Blog tracking for rankings installed. 7982 231
15 8122 Remnant of Giants Blog tracking for rankings installed. 7822 300
16 7760 Gentle Wisdom Blog tracking for rankings installed. 7486 274
17 6749 Observatório Bíblico Blog tracking for rankings installed. 6457 292
18 6595 Alin Suciu Blog tracking for rankings installed. 6449 146
19 6471 Dr. Claude Mariottini – Professor of Old Testament Blog tracking for rankings installed. 6175 296
20 5630 Zwinglius Redivivus 0 5630
21 5026 Participatory Bible Study Blog Blog tracking for rankings installed. 4910 116
22 4632 καὶ τὰ λοιπά Blog tracking for rankings installed. 4513 119
23 4625 Targuman Blog tracking for rankings installed. 4460 165
24 4393 Textuality Blog tracking for rankings installed. 4157 236
25 4324 The Aramaic Blog Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3861 463
26 3938 BibleX Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3580 358
27 3817 Diglotting Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3567 250
28 3656 The Musings of Thomas Verenna Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3341 315
29 3642 NT Pod Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3513 129
30 3225 A ‘Goula Blogger Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3063 162
31 3176 Professor Obvious Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3106 70
32 2980 Ιστολόγιο βιβλικών σπουδών / Biblical Studies Blog 0 2980
33 2821 Aristotle’s Feminist Subject Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1521 1300
34 2362 Grace Commentary Blog tracking for rankings installed. 2334 28
35 2328 5 Minute Bible Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1944 384
36 2306 Pisteuomen Blog tracking for rankings installed. 2212 94
37 1861 Abnormal Interests Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1604 257
38 1788 Ketuvim: the Writings of James R. Getz Jr. Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1729 59
39 1762 The Biblioblog Top 50 Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1622 140
40 1641 Sansblogue Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1515 126
41 1622 Suzanne’s Bookshelf 0 1622
42 1573 Bible Films Blog 0 1573
43 1372 The Forbidden Gospels 0 1372
44 1208 BiblicalStudies.org.uk 0 1208
45 1117 Polumeros kai Polutropos Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1002 115
46 1104 Dust Blog tracking for rankings installed. 889 215
47 676 PaleoJudaica.com 0 676
48 630 AD CUMMULUS Blog tracking for rankings installed. 546 84
49 589 Daniel O. McClellan 0 589
50 542 James’ Thoughts and Musings 0 542

 

Announcements

1) If You Have a Biblioblogging Announcement

As the title says — a sort of announcement-announcement — if you have a Biblioblogging-related announcement and would like it to go out on the month’s Biblioblog Rankings, please email in and (provided it isn’t anything that would make all of us blush) I will include it.

2) More Statistics — As you watch!

The stats system is now completely moved over to the new database and it’s much speedier than before. You can check out the stats in real time (i.e. watch the hits happen) by visiting the following pages:

In the past month, nearly 850 thousand article reads have been recorded. Next month I would not be surprised if this broke 1 million.

3) Call For Submissions: The Biblioblog Reference Library Press

A goal has been set for 10 publications to start the Press off with. So far it looks like we have about 2 or 3 lined up. If you have an idea for a book related to Biblical Studies and have a blog on the List that demonstrates strong knowledge in that area, email in with a prospectus for consideration.

The main focus of the Press is in cross-disciplinary studies and teaching materials, but all ideas (with the exception at this time of fiction, inspirational works, devotionals, or commentaries) are currently being considered.

4) User Accounts on the Library

I know that a large number of you are waiting for the new user accounts to open to the public… but we still have a few more bugs to squash. The test team (about 30 users) is still encountering a few odd errors, but with luck they will be solved by next month, and we can open up user accounts before Christmas.

5) Library-Related Inquiries: A Bit Behind

I am — for lack of a better way to put it — behind with email correspondence. The past month has been very challenging due to some major family transitions, and now to top things off: We’re moving!  Hopefully by Christmas the Caruso clan will be moved in to a bigger, nicer apartment just down the street. So please be assured that yes, I am getting your emails; however, responding to them is a bit slow with all of the planning and packing arrangements. :-)

With all of that said: Until next month!

Peace,
-Steve

Posted in Biblioblog News, Biblioblog Top 50 | 6 Comments »

October’s Biblical Studies Carnival Posted

Posted by Steve Caruso on October 29, 2011

Tom Verenna’s first shot at compiling a Biblical Studies Carnival is now up for all to see a bit early:

Biblical Studies Carnival LXVIII (Tom Verenna, The Musings of Thomas Verenna – October 2011)

Lots of good articles in this one. :-)

This month’s rankings will be posted some time on Tuesday.

Peace,
-Steve

Posted in Biblioblog News | Leave a Comment »

Biblioblog Rankings (by The Biblioblog Library) – September 2011

Posted by Steve Caruso on October 1, 2011

Sorry for not getting this up sooner everyone. With my eldest daughter sick and my grandmother in the hospital, today has gotten away from me a bit. However, now that I have a bit of time to breathe I would like to announce:

This month we have a new #1! Congratulations to Jesus Creed with a whopping ~110k+ views!

Biblioblogs

# Hits Blog Tracker Library
1 109647 Jesus Creed Blog tracking for rankings installed. 108523 1124
2 76027 Debunking Christianity Blog tracking for rankings installed. 75416 611
3 44264 Exploring Our Matrix Blog tracking for rankings installed. 42873 1391
4 32274 Unsettled Christianity Blog tracking for rankings installed. 30420 1854
5 29259 Zwinglius Redivivus Blog tracking *was* installed, but is currently missing. 23009 6250
6 21523 Near Emmaus Blog tracking for rankings installed. 20704 819
7 21422 Ancient Hebrew Poetry Blog tracking for rankings installed. 21211 211
8 18382 Scotteriology Blog tracking for rankings installed. 16546 1836
9 15856 Better Bibles Blog Blog tracking for rankings installed. 15729 127
10 10097 Gentle Wisdom Blog tracking for rankings installed. 9835 262
11 9784 NT Blog Blog tracking for rankings installed. 9626 158
12 9640 Observatório Bíblico Blog tracking for rankings installed. 9237 403
13 8620 Political Jesus Blog tracking for rankings installed. 6431 2189
14 8553 Aantekeningen bij de Bijbel Blog tracking for rankings installed. 8120 433
15 8495 XKV8R: The Official Blog of Dr. Robert R. Cargill Blog tracking for rankings installed. 8311 184
16 7897 Remnant of Giants Blog tracking for rankings installed. 7613 284
17 7346 Alin Suciu Blog tracking for rankings installed. 7233 113
18 7312 Reading Acts Blog tracking for rankings installed. 7068 244
19 5858 The Aramaic Blog Blog tracking for rankings installed. 5427 431
20 5835 Dr. Claude Mariottini – Professor of Old Testament Blog tracking for rankings installed. 5542 293
21 5408 Textuality Blog tracking for rankings installed. 5229 179
22 5122 Participatory Bible Study Blog Blog tracking for rankings installed. 4987 135
23 5089 Targuman Blog tracking for rankings installed. 4918 171
24 4093 BibleX Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3663 430
25 3995 Diglotting Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3752 243
26 3663 NT Pod Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3541 122
27 3316 Aristotle’s Feminist Subject Blog tracking for rankings installed. 2149 1167
28 3312 The Musings of Thomas Verenna Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3071 241
29 3286 A ‘Goula Blogger Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3076 210
30 3251 Professor Obvious Blog tracking for rankings installed. 3197 54
31 2846 Ιστολόγιο βιβλικών σπουδών / Biblical Studies Blog 0 2846
32 2616 Pisteuomen Blog tracking for rankings installed. 2534 82
33 2334 The Biblioblog Top 50 Blog tracking for rankings installed. 2229 105
34 1938 Ketuvim: the Writings of James R. Getz Jr. Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1850 88
35 1799 Abnormal Interests Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1549 250
36 1750 Sansblogue Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1624 126
37 1603 Dust Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1348 255
38 1492 5 Minute Bible Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1105 387
39 1359 Suzanne’s Bookshelf 0 1359
40 1328 Bible Films Blog 0 1328
41 1201 Polumeros kai Polutropos Blog tracking for rankings installed. 1116 85
42 1122 BiblicalStudies.org.uk 0 1122
43 1052 The Forbidden Gospels 0 1052
44 737 PaleoJudaica.com 0 737
45 602 Daniel O. McClellan 0 602
46 570 James’ Thoughts and Musings 0 570
47 444 Euangelion 0 444
48 440 The Biblioblog Reference Librarian’s Desk Blog tracking for rankings installed. 299 141
49 407 The Poetry of Christ Blog tracking for rankings installed. 268 139
50 353 WIT 0 353

I’m glad to see that Biblioblogs are getting such a wide readership.

This Month’s Biblioblog Carnival

The first part (looks like James has started a trend) of the September 2011 Biblioblog Carnival is up over on Scotteriology, so be sure to check it out.

The Biblioblog Reference Library Announcements

This month there are four announcements about the Library:

1) Beta 3 is up – If you haven’t seen the new look yet, I recommend that you check it out. I’ve been told it’s a lot more “gawker-like” which I think is a compliment. :-)

2) A new section about the Jordan Codices has been released – They hit the press back near Easter time and since then, an informal group of Bibliobloggers has shown what distributed review is capable of.

3) In the next week (fingers crossed) user accounts on the Library will be out of testing and open to the public. – What does this mean? Lots of neat things. With a user account, you’ll be able to add new blogs to the list, “claim” blog that are already on it and have some control about how they display, save “portals” or dedicated search feeds which you can share with others, as well as build a public academic profile that you can attach to your blog, your posts, and your comments.

4) The hit counter will go down some time in the next few days and all hits reset to zero as I implement a new hit counting database. – There is so much data (nearly 1 GB dedicated to hits alone) that the old database method is no longer feasible. I’m migrating it to a more robust system that will also (hopefully) fix some problems people have been having with blogs that have multiple URLs.

Until next month!

Peace,
-Steve

Posted in 1, Biblioblog News, Biblioblog Top 50 | 1 Comment »

Snazzy New Feature on The Biblioblog Reference Library

Posted by Steve Caruso on July 9, 2011

So, not only does the tracker keep in mind how many hits each blog gets, but it also can figure out who’s reading what at what times:

  • On the main page of The Biblioblog Reference Library at the top there are now the Six Most Popular Items of the Day (which will look a lot prettier once I get around to it).
  • On the Rankings Page along with the Top 50 Biblioblogs of the month, there are also the Top 10 Articles of the Day and Top 10 Articles of the Month.

If you haven’t installed the tracking code yet, I strongly suggest you do. :-)

Everyone who was on the original Biblioblogs list is now in the new database and can use the tracker, and once I slog through the Related Blogs I’ll be opening up similar lists and rankings for them as well.

Also, if you have any ideas, toss them in my direction.

Peace,
-Steve

Posted in Biblioblog News | 1 Comment »

The New Biblioblog Ranking Tracker

Posted by Steve Caruso on July 5, 2011

Ahoy everyone,


The tracker.

The archived QR code.

The new Biblioblog ranking tracker is up and available to try out here:

http://bibliobloglibrary.wordpress.com/2011/07/05/biblioblog-tracker-archive-qr-code/

If your blog hasn’t been re-added to the recategorized list yet and you want to try out the tracker, drop me an email and I’ll make sure you get on it quicker.

Peace,
-Steve

Posted in Biblioblog News, Biblioblog Top 50 | 12 Comments »

An Open Letter to All Bibliobloggers

Posted by Steve Caruso on July 1, 2011

An Open Letter to Jim, Joel, Rod all other Bibliobloggers pertaining to the Biblioblog Reference Library,

Today I have been made aware of a number of concerns pertaining to the Biblioblog Reference Library. Most of them I feel are either simple misunderstandings or things that are changing in the next week when the Library goes into “Beta 2″; however, please allow me to take a moment to address each of the major concerns in turn.

Overview

I started the Biblioblog Reference Library in April of this year as a good faith effort to try and pull together people who publicly share their thoughts and research in Biblical Studies and allow readers to discover new or common interests and take part in the greater Biblioblogging community. It was originally built upon a WordPress install using a combination of plugins (both public and custom), and received a large amount of praise from all over the Biblioblogosphere (and off it) due to the ability to read through Biblical Studies blogs all in one place. This was a project meant to make things easier for people, and link conversations together to tackle emerging issues and encourage dialog, and that has been the entire thrust of the project from its conception to the present.

Legality

That the Library is “hijacking content” or “violating copyright” is a simple misunderstanding.

Under the law, feeds and other public webpages are subject to an Implied License under Fair Use Doctrine that allows for their archival and indexing in good faith. This is how nearly every search engine (Google, Yahoo, Bing, etc.) and archival system (such as Archive.org) can operate freely without having to obtain permissions for each and every file they scan and index. Problems with illegality tend to crop up when issues such as plagiarism (not citing sources), trademark/dress infringement (impersonating another website or company), or unscrupulous commercial interests (such as “site scraping”; tailoring scraped content to influence Google rankings) come into play, all of which I’m trying to staunchly avoid.

One element of keeping the Implied License in Good Faith is to have some means for owners of content to opt out and have their contributions either hidden or removed entirely. This means was explicitly stated on the “Contact the Librarian” page, and since April, I have received a grand total of 3 requests (including Jim’s) to have blogs removed from the system. This is in contrast to nearly 20 requests for additions that are still pending in queue during the transition.

Let me be unambiguously clear: If I thought that this endeavor was a flagrant violation of copyrights or was illegal, I would have never undertaken it in the first place.

The Library “Takes Away Hits”

This is also another partial misunderstanding, partial change that is soon to take place. The net effect on hits for nearly 90% of all blogs listed has been small, but positive. To explain:

Content from blogs on the Library is displayed in three places:

  • a) On the main page view (which is identical to the search results view),
  • b) In individual page mode with an iframe navigation bar at the bottom that allows readers to move from page to page (thereby enabling one to read the entire feed, or their query, as one large blog) and
  • c) The feed (which will mirrors (a) above).

It is correct that any data listed on the Main Page and in the Search Results view will not directly generate a “hit” to its parent site unless a reader clicks through. In Beta 2 the main page view only displays snippets, not full articles and will hi-light search terms in context. The reason this was not the case in the first Beta is that WordPress’ summary function was clunky and tended to slow things down. This is no longer a problem with the new software, which I have complete control over.

There will also be a means for authors to change the size of the snippets to suit their preferences, where the default length (for both posts *and* comments) will be roughly 200 words.

On the individual page view, no content that is displayed (other than the navigation bar) is from the Reference Library servers. The content is loaded directly from the author’s site to the user’s browser via an iframe, which not only generates a “hit”, but also registers with Alexa, Google, and other search services as an incoming link, thereby *boosting* page rankings.

As of late, roughly 75% of all traffic is in Individual Page mode (with the monthly exception of what seems to be a single individual reading through the entire month’s feeds in search view, right before the monthly Carnival is published ;-) ).

In short: No stolen traffic there, and there’s an incoming link benefit.

If you have a system like Google Analytics, you can even track the traffic coming in from the Library, as it is listed as the referring address.

Where Things Go From Here

Now, in Beta 2 the navigation bar has been completely redone so that there is a more obvious means to remove it and go directly to the page in question, as well as direct access to the archived copies stored on the Reference Library server (think: exactly like Archive.org).

The archives and all query pages except the main page are all marked no-index, so the archived copies or snippets displayed on Library search results will not show up on search engines.

In the next week’s time, the old Beta is going to be depreciated and completely taken down and the Library is moving to a new web address with the brand new software. Where I was hoping to unveil it in its completion, I suppose that now might be the time to get everyone’s input and see if any criticisms are inadequately addressed.

The new site is:

 

Even though this is not “officially” released and is very much incomplete, please (no, seriously *please*) tell me what you think and what can be done to make this something everyone can enjoy.

Biblioblogging is a group effort and I don’t want that to change anytime soon, which is why I formally request anyone who is contemplating removing their blog (or Jim, who already has) to reconsider.

Sincerely,
-Steve Caruso, MLIS
   a.k.a. “The Reference Librarian”

Posted in Biblioblog News | 11 Comments »

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 76 other followers